Welcome to Medary.com Tuesday, November 26 2024 @ 04:34 AM CST

Media coverage of Iraq: The Indictment

  • Contributed by:
  • Views: 3,641
Karl at Protein Wisdom has a long, detailed indictment of "mainstream" media coverage of Iraq:

Take, for example, the coverage of events in Anbar province.  In September-November 2006, the Washington Post ran a series of articles suggesting that the US military was unable to defeat the bloody insurgency in western Iraq “or counter al-Qaeda’s rising popularity there.”  These stories were echoed in the New York Times/International Herald Tribune, The Christian Science Monitor, NBC News, ABC News, CNN, the AP and others, down to local TV.

But this was not the only picture of events in Anbar.  In “Will the Real Anbar Narrative Please Stand Up?”, Bill Ardolino juxtaposed the WaPo stories against analysis by bloggers and embedded reporters like the Times of London’s Martin Fletcher and Michael Fumento for the Weekly Standard.  Bill Roggio’s military and intelligence sources were angry over the media’s characterization of the secret reports cited by the WaPo.  Roggio examined how the claims made in the WaPo coverage were taken out of the larger context of events in Anbar.  Roggio and the Mudville Gazette’s “Greyhawk” charted the formation and rise of the Anbar Salvation Council — the alliance of 25 of the province’s 31 tribes in the fight against al Qaeda.  Roggio and Greyhawk followed up when the Anbar tribes got US air and artillery support — a development ignored by the establishment media.

We now know which narrative was more accurate.  Al Qaeda was not increasingly popular in Anbar.  To the contrary, the local tribes were overwhelmingly opposing and increasingly waging war against al Qaeda, with support from the US military.  Bloggers — carefully following and synthesizing information from their own sources, military information, embedded reporters, Arabic media and isolated stories in the establishment media over the course of a year — proved to be better remote journalists than those at the WaPo, NYT, CSM, AP, CNN, NBC and ABC (and any others I have overlooked).

Much, much more.  People who are interested in getting correct and complete information on Iraq will go to Protein Wisdom and read the entire thing.

In brief

  • Contributed by:
  • Views: 1,411
Michael Vick is getting what's coming to him.  He's reportedly pissed away potential earnings of $100 million because he's too stupid to know that dog fighting is illegal.

Senator Larry Craig needs to resign immediately.  (Parenthetically, so does Representative William Jefferson, Democrat, Louisiana).

Democrats seem to still have problems counting votes in Florida.

They're all poopybutts.

You know, Japan is an odd little country . . .

  • Contributed by:
  • Views: 1,618
Found on Fark.comButt-biting bug munches on Japanese tush in a quest for the golden (be)hind
The Butt-Biting Bug, which is actually supposed to be one of the Little People, first appeared in June on an NHK children's cartoon. The crunching creepy crawly -- who, perhaps unsurprisingly, has roots dating back to ancient Assyria -- skyrocketed to national fame following the release of a CD and DVD on July 27, with stocks of both quickly running out.

Sales and additional orders for both the music and movie have continued flooding in, and a catchy mobile phone ringtone taken from a song about the Butt-Biting Bug and its tush tasting exploits attracts six times more downloads than any other of the dozens available on NHK's site. A children's book starring the fairy came out last week.

Sunday Mainichi notes that the Butt-Biting Bug is actually a fairy, whose nibbles on people's cabooses are supposed to bring them enormous amounts of energy.
Sure, blame the long-dead Assyrians.  (Heh, they said ASSyrians! Guffaw!)

Well, he did seem to be kind of a doofus

  • Contributed by:
  • Views: 1,370
Alberto Gonzales has thrown the towel in as Attorney General.  He will probably not be long remembered, but then, few Attorneys General are.

And, I'm sure he was a poopybutt, as were the chorus of hecklers who hounded him out of office.  Poopybutts, all.

New Glass

  • Contributed by:
  • Views: 1,972
Badger 6, via Blackfive:
We descend off the bridge and that's when you notice the change. When we arrived here the main broad boulevard that traverse the east-west route through the city, with the broad sidewalks had been narrowed down to two and sometimes one lane by concrete barriers, concertina, and debris.

Today the boulevard is wide open and people are walking the streets. Women in abayah's, men in dishdasha, soccer attire, and a few in suits talking on their cell phones. Some people ignore our small convoy, some look suspiciously, and some wave.

There at the first corner, I see it. New glass. Someone has put new glass in a shop. Someone only installs new glass when they think it won't get broken. New glass is confidence.

As we roll though Ramadi I see more stores and small shops open. And more new glass.

We pass what was once a hotel. I am sure the building is so badly damaged that it will need to be razed. I wonder if a hotel will replace it.

Halfway into the city we reach Saddam's Mosque. The area is still a shambles here, but the road has opened up. There are also front end loaders and other heavy equipment moving the concrete and the rebar. Progress has been made, but it will take awhile to truck this away and start rebuilding.
Of course, we are losing in Iraq.  This is what losing looks like, I guess.

UPDATE:  This just in from the amusingly mis-self-named "Reality-Based Community:"  -- all good news from Iraq is a lie.  Because they say so.  Via Confederate Yankee.  Darn that nefarious Karl Rove right to Heck!

The Poopybutt Effect

  • Contributed by:
  • Views: 2,038
Eric at Classical Values has an extended rant on the misuse of the term "fascist" which segues, for some reason, into a discussion of bad sneakers.

I had a pretty good education (at least I like to think I had), and in addition to that, I've read a lot of books about history, including many about the Third Reich. I've studied the origins and rise of both Hitler and Mussolini, and I've read about innumerable fascist and quasi-fascist regimes. The usual stuff like Franco in Spain, Salazar in Portugal, Stroessner in Paraguay, Peron in Argentina (although he was a left/right hybrid), along with some convincing analyses that modern China is actually a fascist, not Communist, state.

But it was under "Bush fascism" that I noticed a steady deterioration in my skills. Not only was I not "getting it" (and failing to recognize the fascism before my very eyes), but a lot of people weren't. I don't know whether to blame Bush entirely for this, but it was during the Bush regime that the definition of fascism seemed to change dramatically, and become infinitely more complicated.

I used to think I knew what fascism was, but the longer Bush was in office, the more the word seemed to take on new meanings. It was as if the word "fascism" had developed an elasticized penumbra, and acquired octopus-like tentacles which reached out and engulfed things which in the old days had not been considered fascism, but which now were. Fascist hegemony was being achieved not by goose-stepping soldiers, but by definitional expansionism -- largely accomplished by computer keyboards.

This put me in mind of the ritual name-calling which passes for political discussion nowadays.  I had a thought for an ongoing feature--I'd go find various inflammatory blog articles and replace the relevant political flame-word ("liberal," "conservative," "fascist," "leftist," "right-wing," "reality-based community") with the term "poopy-butt."

This would in my opinion raise both the level of political discourse, and provide hours of amusement.  We'll see how it goes.

You blinked, didn't you . . .

  • Contributed by:
  • Views: 2,374
CENTRAL W L Pct GB RS RA L10 Str
Cleveland 68 56 .548 614 566 4-6 L2
Detroit 68 57 .544 1/2 694 638 5-5 W1
Minnesota 62 63 .496 7 554 551 4-6 L2
Chicago 56 69 .448 13 536 646 2-8 W2
Kansas City 55 70 .440 14 568 603 4-6 L3

Don't blink but the Royals aren't in last place

  • Contributed by:
  • Views: 2,434
The Kansas City Royals have, for the moment, climbed out of last place in the American League Central division with a 2-1 series win over Oakland.  The Royals' series win relegates the Chicago White Sox to the AL Central basement.

CENTRAL W L Pct GB RS RA L10 Str
Cleveland 68 55 .553 613 564 4-6 L1
Detroit 67 57 .540 1 1/2 692 637 4-6 L3
Minnesota 62 61 .504 6 548 535 4-6 W1
Kansas City 55 68 .447 13 563 594 5-5 L1
Chicago 54 69 .439 14 527 641 1-9 L8


Who do the Royals play next?  Why, the White Sox, in Chicago.

Artificial life likely in 3-10 years

  • Contributed by:
  • Views: 1,730
Kansas City Star/AP:

Experts expect an announcement within three to 10 years from someone in the now little-known field of "wet artificial life."

"It's going to be a big deal and everybody's going to know about it," said Mark Bedau, chief operating officer of ProtoLife of Venice, Italy, one of those in the race. "We're talking about a technology that could change our world in pretty fundamental ways - in fact, in ways that are impossible to predict."

That first cell of synthetic life - made from the basic chemicals in DNA - may not seem like much to non-scientists. For one thing, you'll have to look in a microscope to see it.